myHotTake

Tag: integration tests

  • Integration vs E2E Tests in JavaScript: What’s the Difference?

    Hey there! If you find this story intriguing, feel free to like or share it with your friends who might also enjoy a little tech storytelling.


    I’m in charge of organizing a library of digital files. My task is to sort these files alphabetically, but I have two different methods to achieve it. I call the first method “Integration Sorting” and the second one “End-to-End Sorting.”

    When I dive into Integration Sorting, it feels like I’m focusing on clusters of files. I take one shelf at a time, making sure that the files on each shelf are neatly arranged from A to Z. I’m like a librarian ensuring each section of the library is in perfect order. I don’t worry about how the files got to that shelf or where they’ll head next; my responsibility is just to ensure that within each section, everything is in its rightful place. It’s about ensuring that each piece of the puzzle fits perfectly within its own boundaries, and I can automate this process with a script that checks and organizes each shelf independently.

    Now, let’s switch to the End-to-End Sorting adventure. Here, I picture myself overseeing the entire library from the moment a file enters the building to when it’s placed on its shelf. I’m not just sorting individual shelves; I’m ensuring the entire flow of the library is seamless. It’s like a choreography where every step is crucial. I automate this sorting process by creating a script that mimics a file’s journey through the library, ensuring it passes through all the right steps and ends up in its final, correct spot, alphabetically in line with every other file in the library.

    Both methods are about sorting, but the scale and focus are different. Integration Sorting is like polishing each individual gemstone, ensuring its brilliance, while End-to-End Sorting is about crafting the entire necklace, ensuring each gem is perfectly placed in the design.


    Returning to my digital library, I realize that the sorting script is written in JavaScript. For Integration Sorting, I focus on individual sections of the system. Let’s imagine I’m using a JavaScript function to alphabetically organize files on a single shelf. Here’s a snippet of what that might look like:

    function sortShelf(files) {
      return files.sort((a, b) => a.localeCompare(b));
    }
    
    // Integration test for sorting a single shelf
    describe('sortShelf', () => {
      it('should sort files alphabetically', () => {
        const shelf = ['banana.txt', 'apple.txt', 'cherry.txt'];
        const sortedShelf = ['apple.txt', 'banana.txt', 'cherry.txt'];
        expect(sortShelf(shelf)).toEqual(sortedShelf);
      });
    });

    In this test, I’m ensuring that the sortShelf function correctly sorts a single shelf, much like how I would focus on one section of the library. The test checks only this specific piece of functionality, verifying that files on this particular shelf are sorted as expected.

    Now, when I switch to End-to-End Sorting, I want to simulate the entire process of a file entering the library, being sorted, and then placed correctly. Here’s how I might use a tool like Puppeteer or Cypress to automate this flow:

    // E2E test using a framework like Cypress
    describe('Library E2E Test', () => {
      it('should process and sort a file correctly from entry to final placement', () => {
        cy.visit('/library');
        cy.uploadFile('document.txt');
        cy.get('[data-shelf="A"]').contains('document.txt').should('exist');
      });
    });

    In this E2E test, I’m ensuring that a file uploaded to the library ends up in the right place on the right shelf, simulating the entire journey through the system. This is akin to overseeing the whole library’s operation, ensuring each part of the system works together seamlessly.

    Key Takeaways:

    1. Integration Tests: Focus on individual components or functions, like sorting a single shelf. They’re quicker and usually isolate specific parts of the code.
    2. E2E Tests: Simulate the complete workflow, ensuring the entire system works as expected, like overseeing the entire library process from entry to final placement.
    3. JavaScript Tools: Use libraries like Jest for integration tests and tools like Cypress or Puppeteer for E2E tests to automate these processes.